Boston, Belfast or Bust!

I was recently discussing the Boston Matrix with a client as we tried to establish the balance of which products and services he should be focusing on. If you haven’t thought of using the Boston Matrix it could be of use to you and if you have used it before, I thought it was time we tried to Northern Ireland it up, make it more the Belfast Matrix.

Basically the Boston Consultancy Group (BCG) created a matrix where they advise analysing customers/products/services into four categories so we know where to focus our energy and termed them:- the Cash Cow, the Dogs, the Stars and the Question Marks.

We’ll start with the Cash Cow, a term already well known in Northern Ireland, not to be confused with “That Aul Cow”, which is a completely different animal all together. Your cash cows are well established products, you have been working with them for a long time, they make money but have limited growth potential, every business needs these cash generators but if you focus solely on them and nothing else, they will eventually fade away and you will have no business left. You must take the money from these and put it into other growth areas. So for our Belfast Matrix I thought we would use the Giants Causeway for this; it’s around for years, has a high share of the Tourism market but could have limited growth potential. (It is highly unlikely we can find another giant to fire a few more stones into the sea). Anyway given current milk prices it’s a bit dangerous even mentioning cows so we’ll move swiftly on to Dogs.

The Dogs are the products that you shouldn’t be involved in, you don’t have a large amount of these and you don’t make money on them so you should stop doing these and focus on the other three categories. In our Belfast Matrix this has to be the Titanic, it’s the sinking ship in your business, no doubt you will have already asked yourself, why am I dealing with these? If you focus too heavily in this sector you will be Bust. Quite simply you should get out and stay out of this sector and don’t wait until the dog bites.

The Stars:- Everybody wants these. Stars are things you are good at, are highly profitable and you are established in the market. They differ from the cash cows simply in that they have high growth potential and stars can eventually turn into cash cows. Our Belfast Matrix has these as Terex or Bushmills:- Highly established, profitable businesses with continued growth potential. You must recognise and focus on these in your business. The money from Stars and Cash Cows should be reinvested in more Stars with some set aside for Question Marks.

The Question Marks (sometimes referred to as Problem Childs) are the items where you could spend all your time, you don’t have a lot of them, they are not profitable right now but you think they have great potential; however they could go either way become a star or a dog; you are not really sure. The initial people for our own Matrix jumping to mind were George Best and Rory McIlroy, both brilliant but could easily throw it away by messing about, however they really are both established brilliant Stars so I thought for our Belfast Matrix we have to use the Northern Ireland Assembly. Our own assembly could have great potential, it could help N Ireland become a Star in the World Economy or it could turn out to be a Titanic. You must invest some time and money into the Question Marks or you won’t identify the new Stars, but make sure it is only a percentage as if all your focus is here you won’t generate enough cash and we are back to Bust again.

I was going to draw out my new Belfast Matrix but before doing so if you can think of better alternatives than those I mentioned, let me know. Now I have nothing at all against Boston but while we are at it lets see if we can rebrand that Tea Party.

Julian McKeown

 

https://www.abacni.co.uk/category/articles/